Skip to main content Scroll Top

Employment Agreements 101: Avoiding the Most Common NZ Compliance Mistakes

The most common employment agreement mistakes NZ small businesses make, and a practical checklist for getting documentation right from day one.

Employment Agreements 101: avoiding the most common NZ compliance mistakes, S Wallace Consulting

Why employment agreements catch small businesses out

Under New Zealand’s Employment Relations Act 2000, every employee must have a written employment agreement, and it must be provided before or as soon as reasonably practicable after they start. This sounds simple, but it is one of the most common compliance gaps we see in small and growing businesses: agreements copied from a template years ago, never updated, missing key clauses, or simply never signed.

These gaps rarely cause a problem until there is a dispute, a restructure, or an employment relations claim, at which point an out-of-date or incomplete agreement can turn a manageable situation into a costly one.

A practical checklist for employment documentation

  • Every employee has a signed, current agreement — including casual, part-time, and long-serving staff who may still be on an old template.
  • Trial and probationary clauses are used correctly — 90-day trial periods are available to all employers regardless of size since December 2023, but the clause must be agreed in writing and in good faith before the employee starts, and correctly worded, or it won’t hold up.
  • Hours, pay, and leave entitlements are current — matching actual working arrangements, not just what was agreed at hiring.
  • Restraint of trade and confidentiality clauses are realistic — overly broad clauses are difficult to enforce and can create false confidence.
  • A documented disciplinary and dispute process exists — so that if something does go wrong, your business follows a fair and defensible process.
  • Records are kept — wage and time records, leave records, and signed variations, in line with your legal record-keeping obligations.

The mistakes we see most often

The single biggest mistake is treating the employment agreement as a one-off document rather than something that should evolve with the role. A job that has changed significantly since hiring, more responsibility, different hours, a different reporting line, should have that reflected in a variation to the agreement, agreed and signed by both parties.

Other frequent issues: using a trial period clause without meeting the legal requirements to rely on it; verbal changes to pay or hours that are never documented; and template agreements that reference outdated legislation or leave entitlements. Good record-keeping matters just as much as the agreement itself, in the same way it does for health and safety training and induction records — documentation only protects you if it is current and can be produced when needed.

Frequently asked questions

Do casual and part-time staff need a written employment agreement?

Yes. Every employee, regardless of hours or employment type, is legally entitled to a written employment agreement in New Zealand. Casual arrangements still need clear terms covering how and when work is offered and accepted.

Can I use the same employment agreement template for every role?

A consistent base template is fine, but role-specific details, hours, duties, reporting lines, and any relevant restraint or confidentiality clauses should be tailored. A generic template that does not reflect the actual role is harder to rely on if a dispute arises.

What happens if an employee never signed their agreement?

An employment relationship and its basic obligations still exist even without a signed document, but an unsigned or missing agreement makes it much harder to demonstrate agreed terms, trial periods, or specific clauses if a dispute occurs. Getting agreements signed and filed should be treated as a priority, not a formality.

How often should employment agreements be reviewed?

Whenever a role, pay, or hours changes materially, and as a general check at least every one to two years to make sure agreements still reflect current legislation and actual working arrangements.

Get your employment documentation right

S Wallace Consulting helps New Zealand small businesses review and rebuild employment documentation so it protects both the business and its people. We can also help with contractor agreements where roles sit outside standard employment.

SW
Shireen Wallace

Founder of S Wallace Consulting, with more than 30 years of cross-sector experience in compliance, policies and records management. Professional Member of ARANZ. Read more about Shireen.

Get our free NZ compliance checklists

Choose your organisation type and we will email you the right set of checklists, plus occasional practical compliance tips.

Related Posts